HBP Scene-by-Scene SuperPoll

[James]

I know the last scene is out of order but I wasn't sure where it was exactly. Some scenes have been split because I thought it was nessicary - others grouped together or left out because I can only have 35 poll options.

Check the scenes that you were happy with (the vast majority of it, overall, you know) and vote, then reply here with your comments! You can retract your vote if you change your mind. Thanks to the Mugglenet Chamber of Secrets Forums, which I used as a resource for listing the scenes.

Would post with my own personal comments but I just spent ages making the poll so I'll leave it at that for now.

Eager for your votes and opinions.

(Just quickly though - I really really hated that shoelace scene... and how Tonks and Lupin's relationship was done... but Lavender on the Hogwarts Express makes up for it so I gave that part the tick.)

[Madame Lee]

I was REALLY dissaponted with the Quidditch. Where was "Weasley is our King?" All of a sudden this wasn't shown up. Dumdledore's Funeral was not in it either. The movie was also very flash-like. Like, they didn't stick with a single scene for more than five minutes.

However, I enjoyed it more than disliked it. I mean, the movie was like 3 hours long, right? I wouldn't have sat there any longer, which is why I understand that some things neeed to be cut.

Great Movie, all in all.

[Suki Samini]

Jul 16, 2009 5:55:18 GMT -7 Madame Lee said:

I was REALLY dissaponted with the Quidditch. Where was "Weasley is our King?" All of a sudden this wasn't shown up. Dumdledore's Funeral was not in it either.

I have to agree with this. The first things that went through my mind when I left the theater were about the funeral and "Weasley is our King". I understand the need to cut things out and shorten things up for the audience's sake, but some things are just too good to leave out.

I have to admit I hoped for a bit more at Weasley's Wizard Wheezes simply because I find Fred and George the best part of many of the books. But in all honesty the scene with Ron and the twins mad up for it....slightly.....

Ron and the love potion was well worth the wait. That scene was absolutely priceless, nothing else to be said about it.

The one other thing I remember distinctly from the movie was Hermione and the canaries. It wasn't exactly like the book if I recall correctly, I just find it hilarious because I can picture a girl doing that.